Your swimming pool is the heart of your backyard, a place for relaxation, family fun, and making memories. But over time, even the most beloved pool can start to show its age. Cracks might appear, the plaster may stain, or the design might simply feel dated. When you decide it’s time for an upgrade, you’ll encounter two terms: renovation and remodel.
While often used interchangeably, these words describe very different types of projects. Understanding the distinction is crucial for setting a realistic budget, timeline, and vision for your backyard oasis. A renovation focuses on restoring your pool to its former glory, while a remodel aims to transform it into something new.
This guide will break down the differences between a pool renovation and a pool remodel. We’ll explore the scope of each, the costs involved, and the key factors to consider, so you can make an informed decision that brings your dream pool to life.
What is a Pool Renovation?
A pool renovation is the process of repairing, updating, or upgrading an existing pool to improve its appearance, safety, and functionality without completely rebuilding it.
Common Pool Renovation Projects
If your pool’s “bones” are good but it needs a significant facelift, a renovation is likely what you need. These projects typically address wear and tear that happens over years of use and exposure to the elements.
- Resurfacing: This is one of the most common renovation tasks. Over time, plaster, pebble, or aggregate surfaces can stain, crack, or become rough. Resurfacing involves chipping away the old material and applying a fresh layer, instantly making your pool look brand new.
- Tile and Coping Repair: The tiles at your pool’s waterline can chip, and the coping (the stone or concrete edge) can crack or become loose. A renovation would involve replacing damaged tiles and repairing or replacing the coping to ensure a clean, safe edge.
- Deck Restoration: Your pool deck takes a beating from the sun and water. Renovation work here might include pressure washing, repairing cracks in the concrete, applying a new coating or sealant, or replacing a few broken pavers.
- Equipment Upgrades: This is a key part of modernizing your pool. A renovation can include replacing an old, inefficient pump with a variable-speed model, installing a new filter system for clearer water, or adding a salt chlorine generator for softer, gentler sanitation.
The Scope and Cost of a Renovation
A pool renovation is less invasive than a remodel. The work is largely cosmetic and functional, preserving the pool’s original size, shape, and location. Because you aren’t making structural changes, the permit process is often simpler, and the project timeline is shorter—usually taking a few days to a few weeks.
Consequently, a renovation is the more budget-friendly option. The final cost depends on the size of your pool and the extent of the updates, but it is significantly less than a full remodel.
What is a Pool Remodel?
A pool remodel is a complete transformation. This type of project involves altering the core structure, size, shape, or features of your pool. If you’re looking to fundamentally change how your pool looks and functions, you’re planning a remodel. It’s less about restoring what you have and more about creating something entirely different.
Common Pool Remodel Projects
A remodel opens up a world of possibilities for customizing your pool. These are large-scale projects that often require an experienced designer and contractor.
- Changing Pool Shape or Size: Have you always wanted a freeform lagoon shape instead of your rectangular pool? Or do you need to make your pool smaller to create more patio space? A remodel can make it happen. This involves extensive demolition and construction.
- Altering the Depth: Many older pools were built with a very deep end for diving. Today, many homeowners prefer a shallower, more recreation-friendly depth. A remodel can raise the pool floor to create a “sport pool” with a consistent depth, perfect for games like volleyball.
- Adding Water Features: This is where a remodel truly shines. You can add features that completely change the ambiance of your backyard, such as:
- Waterfalls: Create a tropical feel with a rock waterfall.
- Fountains and Bubblers: Add elegant streams of water for a sophisticated look.
- Tanning Ledges: Also known as Baja shelves, these are large, shallow steps perfect for lounging in a few inches of water.
- Integrating a Spa: Adding a hot tub that flows into your pool is a popular remodel project. This creates a year-round attraction and a luxurious feel.
- Major Deck and Patio Overhaul: A remodel isn’t just about the pool itself. It often includes expanding or completely reconfiguring the surrounding patio, building an outdoor kitchen, or adding a fire pit area.
The Scope and Cost of a Remodel
A pool remodel is a major construction project. It involves significant demolition, plumbing and electrical rerouting, steel reinforcement, and extensive concrete work. Because you are altering the structure, you will almost certainly need detailed plans and building permits from your local municipality.
The timeline is much longer, often spanning several weeks or even months, depending on the complexity. As you would expect, the cost is substantially higher than a renovation. A remodel is a significant investment in your property, but it also provides a significant return in both enjoyment and home value.
Renovation vs. Remodel: A Quick Comparison
| Feature | Pool Renovation | Pool Remodel |
| Primary Goal | Restore and update | Transform and redesign |
| Scope | Surface-level and equipment | Structural and aesthetic |
| Key Activities | Resurfacing, tile repair, deck refinishing | Changing shape, adding features, altering depth |
| Permits | Sometimes, depending on the job | Almost always required |
| Timeline | Days to weeks | Weeks to months |
| Cost | Lower | Higher |
| Best For | Pools with good structure but signs of age | Outdated pools or new backyard visions |
How to Choose the Right Project for Your Pool
Deciding between a renovation and a remodel comes down to three key factors:
- Your Vision: What do you want to achieve? Are you happy with your pool’s basic layout and just want it to look new and function better? A renovation is your answer. Or are you dreaming of a completely different backyard experience with new features and a modern design? Then it’s time for a remodel.
- Your Budget: Be realistic about what you can afford. A renovation can provide a stunning refresh for a modest investment. A remodel is a significant financial commitment, so you need to plan accordingly. Get quotes for both scenarios to see what is feasible.
- Your Pool’s Condition: If your pool has major structural issues, like significant cracks in the shell or obsolete plumbing, a remodel might be necessary to address these foundational problems properly. If the structure is sound, a renovation can handle the rest.
Ready to Transform Your Pool?
Whether your pool needs a simple refresh or a complete overhaul, understanding the difference between a renovation and a remodel is the first step toward a successful project. A renovation restores its beauty, while a remodel redefines its character. Both paths lead to a more enjoyable and valuable backyard.
If you’re ready to explore the possibilities for your pool, we can help. Contact us today for a professional consultation. Our team will assess your pool, listen to your ideas, and help you create a plan that fits your vision and budget.
Looking to upgrade your pool? Contact Estate Renovation today. Our experts deliver quality pool renovation Sydney services that fit your style and budget.